The smoke that had filled the grand ballroom of the Astoria World Manor slowly began to clear as the cooking was winding down. Between endless samples of libations, including sangria, Sapporro, and sorbet made from wine, the crowd managed to either muster up -- or at least feign -- sobriety and focus on the activities in front of them. After all, they were not just attendees at the 6th Annual Cuisine of Queens & Beyond, nor, despite appearances, were they extras being filmed for an upcoming episode of Ugly Betty. They were all witnesses to New York food history.
Whether you're a lover of White Castle, brag about the three-meat blend in your own otherwise secret recipe, or are willing to spend $175 for Kobe beef, foie gras, and black truffles stuffed between two pieces of bread, everyone is a critic when it comes to burgers. To set the bar for what makes the ideal sandwich, this year Dish du Jour Magazine's food and wine event introduced a cooking competition to the usual tasting festivities, complete with some of the better-known New York based food personalities: the Burger Battle of the Boroughs.
Griddles, timers, cast iron pans, meat grinders, a seemingly endless supply of Heinz ketchup, and even a blowtorch. These were just some of the supplies furnished and used by the seven fierce competitors, representing four of New York's five boroughs. The event was hosted by Dish du Jour Magazine's Chef Armand and led by emcee and hamburger documentarian George Motz. The judging panel was comprised of a colorful mesh of well-known foodies -- Josh Ozersky from New York Magazine's Grub Street; Arthur "Food Maven" Schwartz; the model-esque Kelly Choi, host of Eat Out New York (who also had a camera crew documenting the event for her show); chef Terrance Brennan of Artisanal; and Tony Tantillo, food expert for CBS2 HD.
Competitors included Brgr and Resto representing Manhattan, Farm on Adderely and 67 Burger representing Brooklyn, Harry’s Water Beach Taxi and Joe's Bestburger representing Queens, and Coals representing the Bronx. No one really had an answer as to why Staten Island was not on board.
The competition was a whirlwind 40 minutes and the competitors cooking times were scattered so that a fresh, new burger arrived to the judges every few moments. Each burger was assigned a number and the judges were seated in front of the cooks to ensure a blind tasting. A burger could earn up to 20 points: up to 5 points for Appearance, 5 points for Originality, and up to 10 points for Taste.
As the burgers arrived for the judges' inspection, each had its little indosyncrasies. Some had english muffins instead of buns, while others were topped with blue cheese or bacon laden. There were double deckers, flame-melted cheese, grilled, pan-fried burgers, and more. The burger that was declared the winner had a simplistic, all-American soul that sat well with the judges. It was comprised of fresh, juicy meat sandwiched between a buttery toasted bun, and was accompanied with little more than pickles, tomato, and a dab of a Russian dressing-like sauce. Two bites in, Josh Ozerky held the burger, looked towards Kelly Choi and Tony Tantillo, and quietly proclaimed, "It just feels right to me. It feels like a burger." The winner: Queen's own Harry's Water Beach and Taxi.
The judging panel awaits the first team's burger.

Dish du Jour's Chef Armand discusses what makes a perfect burger with Arthur Schwartz.

The evening's emcee George "Hamburger" Motz overlooks the judging table.

Chef Terrance Brannan matter-of-factly explains his ideal burger would include -- surprise -- Artisanal cheeses.

A burger could earn up to 20 points (5 Appearance, 5 Originality, and 10 Taste).

Councilman Peter Vallone putting his two cents in.


"It just feels right to me. It feels like a burger," uttered Josh Ozersky as he examined burger number 6, which was soon to become the "Best Burger in the Boroughs."

Burger King: Harry Hawk of Harry's Water Beach and Taxi accepts his prize.
Images by Anna Papoutsakis
Recent Comments